Wilmette's Teardown Fee Debate Assumes the Teardowns Keep Coming
October 8, 2026
October 8, 2026
At the southeast corner of Lake Avenue and Locust Road, a single-family house with an attached garage sits on a parcel of just over 26,000 square feet. On May 5, 2026, Wilmette's Plan Commission voted unanimously to approve a request from the applicant, listed as 2645 Lake LLC, to split that parcel into three lots of 8,760, 8,880 and 9,000 square feet, with a new single-family home planned for each. According to property records cited by The Record North Shore, the site sold for $1.03 million earlier in 2026.
Divide that price by three and you get about $343,000 per future lot. That figure comes before demolition, construction, tree mitigation or village fees. For anyone shopping Wilmette's older, smaller homes, the buyer on the other side of an offer is often valuing the dirt rather than the house.
The Lake Avenue plan needed no variations. Wilmette's R1-A single-family district sets a minimum lot of 8,400 square feet and 60 feet of width. Each proposed lot clears both, at 60 feet or more wide and 120 feet or more deep. The Village Board still has to review the plat. A tree survey had not been finished when the commission voted, and the village's tree preservation ordinance requires replacement plantings or a payment in lieu when healthy trees come down.
Acting Chair Mariah DiGrino described how narrow the commission's role was:
"The matter before us tonight is a very limited-scope matter: Does the proposed lot configuration conform to the requirements of the subdivision ordinance, mainly does it create lots that are of the required minimum size and dimensions required under the code."
That quote holds the mechanism. If a parcel meets the code's dimensions, the math works for whoever can see the lots inside it. Most Wilmette parcels can't be split three ways. The same logic still applies at a smaller scale whenever a modest house sits on a lot that would support something much larger.
Wilmette charges a flat $4,500 for a residential demolition, and the money goes into the general municipal budget. At a July 13, 2026 community conversation on the village's draft Housing Plan, Jane Hornstein of BRicK Partners, part of the consultant team working with the Metropolitan Mayors Caucus, compared that fee with neighboring communities.
| Community | Residential demolition fee | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Wilmette, current | $4,500 flat, to the general budget | Draft Housing Plan, Strategy 1.3 |
| Evanston, Northbrook, Highland Park | $15,000 to $20,000 | July 13, 2026 Housing Commission minutes |
| Wilmette, modeled in the draft plan | $20,000, to a new Housing Trust Fund | Draft Housing Plan, Strategy 1.3 |
The draft describes $20,000 as "in-line with Evanston and close to that of Northbrook and Highland Park." It also lists Lake Forest among the neighbors that fund housing trust funds partly through demolition fees. Hornstein said the actual amount would be up to the Village Board.
The draft's revenue projection is the clearest guide to how this proposal would likely play out. The plan multiplies a $20,000 fee by Wilmette's average of 23 residential demolitions a year from 2008 through 2025 and arrives at about $460,000 a year for a Housing Trust Fund. That would pay for about four Community Land Trust homes a year, at just over $100,000 of subsidy per home.
The model only works if the teardowns continue at about their historical pace. The fee is designed to collect revenue from demolitions. It does not assume they stop.
The size of the fee supports that reading. Wilmette's June 18, 2026 Housing Commission presentation put the median value of a 1950s-era home at $640,000 in 2024. A $20,000 fee comes to about 3% of that figure. At Lake Avenue, it would be under 2% of the $1.03 million purchase price. A builder already planning around lot cost, construction and tree replacement would see a higher fee as one more cost line, and probably not enough by itself to cancel a project.
The fee money would go into a new Housing Trust Fund, which the draft says could then be used to add homes to the village's existing Community Land Trust, run with Community Partners for Affordable Housing. The trust was started with a $1.6 million developer contribution from Optima Verdana and has bought 15 homes so far. Under that model, the trust keeps the land, the buyer owns the house and pays a land lease that typically runs $25 to $50 a month, and resale is limited to another income-qualified buyer. In effect, a few smaller houses a year would come off the open market for good. For an open-market buyer, the pool of older, smaller homes would stay roughly the same size, or shrink slightly.
The same June presentation showed how quickly that pool has gained value. Median values by decade built, 2014 to 2024:
The 1950s group rose about 44% over that decade. The village's slide says mid-century homes "have seen some of the fastest increases in values in recent years." Those are valuation figures, not closed sales, and the presentation does not explain how they were calculated.
Recent closings show where those homes now sit in the market. Resideline Market Watch tracked 234 Wilmette closings in the six months through its October 3, 2026 update. The median price was $1,102,500, and the middle half of sales closed between $700,000 and $1,725,000. Its lowest band, $349,000 to $839,000, held 73 of those sales, the most of any band. Median price per square foot was $465 in May 2026, $453 in each of June, July and August, and $449 in September. The September figure is preliminary, based on 22 qualifying sales so far. Median time from listing to contract was 28 days. These figures cover a tracked sample, and Resideline notes that its coverage may differ from county records.
Steady pricing near $450 a square foot, with about four weeks from listing to contract, does not point to a market where land buyers are backing off. In practice, a buyer bidding on a modest older ranch or Cape is competing for the same sales as someone who prices the property by what can be built there.
Smaller-home buyers may also start comparing older houses with new condos. Optima Lumina is planned for 721–739 Green Bay Road, the former Imperial Motors site. At its July 2026 sales launch, reported starting prices were $595,000 for a one-bedroom, $895,000 for a two-bedroom, $1.99 million for a three-bedroom and $4.59 million for a four-bedroom. A new one-bedroom condo now starts within about $45,000 of the 2024 median value of a 1950s Wilmette house.
According to The Record North Shore, trustees amended the agreement on August 25 to allow up to 133 for-sale residences. Buyers can combine adjacent units, and five ground-floor homes can include lower-level space reached by a private stair. Optima expects that once buyers combine units, the final count will be 128 or fewer. The agreement also includes a $3.815 million contribution toward affordable housing in Wilmette.
The timing is not settled. Village officials said Optima had not applied for construction permits as of August 25. Optima's timeline suggests construction could begin in 2026, with residents arriving as soon as summer 2028. A July 27 village counsel memo kept the original permit deadline of October 8, 2026, five days from now.
The fee is a proposal, not a rule. As of the Housing Commission's September 17, 2026 meeting, members were still discussing a first draft of the plan and did not take a recommendation vote. The next meeting is November 19. Village Board materials from July 28 through September 22 show no fee vote or hearing. Deputy Director of Community Development Jodi Luka has said the Housing Plan does not change zoning on its own. Any change would go through a longer process with the Village Board.
Dates to watch:
The draft also suggests longer-term changes, including more housing in the Village Center, Ridge Road, Linden Square and Skokie Boulevard business districts, a review of floor-area-ratio limits, and Wilmette-specific rules for middle housing and accessory dwelling units. Those ideas could eventually add smaller-home options in different forms. None of them is in effect today.
The village has not made that claim. Its draft treats the fee as a funding source and assumes about 23 demolitions a year continue. At $20,000, the fee would be a small share of a typical lot purchase, so it is unlikely by itself to change what builders will pay.
Yes. The Plan Commission's approval only confirmed that the lot dimensions meet the code. The plat still needs Village Board approval, and the commission's acting chair said the pending tree survey could make the three-lot layout unworkable.
The figures are reported launch prices from July 2026, not closed sales. Availability and pricing may have changed since then.
When an older Wilmette home goes on the market, the strongest offer may come from someone pricing the lot. The Leigh Marcus Team can show how comparable mid-century sales and recent lot activity apply to a specific address before you write an offer or set a list price. Book a Consultation.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.
2203 W Roscoe St Chicago, IL 60618 30 Green Bay Road Winnetka, IL 60093